|
| |
|
Archives for December 2008 |
|
This page lists our postings from all of December
|
|
For an index to all our reports
and analyses
on the 219th General Assembly
For links to
all our archive pages, listed by months,
click here. |
|
12/31/08 May this
New Year bring you (and our world) true happiness -- peace and
fulfillment for all |
| From the leadership of the
PC(USA): Prayer for Peace in Gaza
Even as we celebrate the birth of the Prince of Peace, we
are anguished by stories of violence and conflict once again in Gaza [www.pcusa.org/worldwide/israelpalestine].
Citizens and soldiers, young people and old are wounded and killed. We see
how violence begets violence, as an eye for an eye leads not to peace, but
to deeper blindness. We pray fervently for peace, for a New Year marked by a
willingness and commitment to put violence aside and a desire and dedication
to seek new relationships of peace. We pray that governments and leaders
here and there and around the world will use whatever influence they may
have as peacemakers, and that we, too will have courage and faith to pray
without ceasing and to be agents of justice and peace for all.
Bruce Reyes-Chow, Moderator
Gradye Parsons, Stated Clerk
Linda Valentine, Executive Director, General Assembly Council |
| More
on the Israeli attacks against Gaza
The Presbyterian
Peacemaking Program offers suggestions for action, and sources of
information.
A few critical looks at Israel’s attack on Gaza –
mostly through Jewish eyes
 |
Palestinian doctor refutes several of Israel’s justifications for
its attacks on Gaza
|
 |
Phyllis Bennis,
of the Institute for Policy Studies, analyzes Israel's actions under
these main points: |
The Israeli airstrikes represent serious
violations of international law С including the Geneva Conventions
and a range of international humanitarian law.
The U.S. is complicit in the Israeli violations С
directly and indirectly.
The timing of the air strikes has far more to do
with U.S. and Israeli politics than with protecting Israeli
civilians.
This serious escalation will push back any chance
of serious negotiations between the parties that might have been
part of the Obama administration's plans.
There is much work to be done.
 | Other good sources of information include
Jewish Peace
News offers a vast amount of information
(such as the pieces above) from many different sources, and
Jewish Voice for Peace, which reflects the
U.S.-based Jewish peace-activist orientation of the group.
|
 |
A Hundred Eyes for an Eye
Writing for Truthout,
Norman Solomon says:
Even if you set aside
the magnitude of Israel's violations of the Geneva conventions and
the long terrible history of its methodical collective punishment of
1.5 million Palestinians in Gaza, consider the vastly
disproportionate carnage in the conflict. 'An eye for an eye makes
the whole world blind,' Gandhi said. What about a hundred eyes for
an eye?
The rest of the article >>
|
 |
A different point of view:
It's Overtime for Hamas' Leaders and Time for Them
to Go
Former Ambassador Marc Ginsberg argues that "the only
way out of this mess is to separate Hamas' entire military and political
leadership from the oppressed citizenry of Gaza (and yes, it is
absolutely a mischaracterization of fact to assert that Hamas is the
legitimate ruler of Gaza)."
More >> |
|
|
12/25/08 |
A poem for Christmas
O come, you Splendor very bright,
as joy that never yields to might.
O come and twin all hearts to peace,
that greed and war at last shall cease.
— translated from the Latin of a
very early carol,
“O Come, O Come, Emmanuel
JOURNEY
Wisdom’s representatives lurched across the desert on camel back— obedient to celestial mandate, ready to pay homage at a royal birth. Spines jarred by days of riding ached for respite that never came. Fur-trimmed robes already carried stains of night encampments. Hours of quiet study and scholars’
conversation— this trio’s normal practice— now seemed luxury lost.
Journey’s end heaped
disappointment on discomfort. The travelers knelt before an infant just as they had planned, and handed over tributes of great value. Nothing else developed as expected— no elegant reception, no regal fanfare— only the couple and their baby surrounded by some cattle in a barn.
In years to come these men
would often wonder They heard rumors of this child become a man— preaching loving kindness, urging peace. What if his message does catch on, is imitated by the many, supplanting the greed on which the world too often turns?
We wonder still.
jk, 12/2008
John D. King, Bloomington, Indiana
Your WebWeaver thanks his brother
Jack for this contribution.
More Christmas
reflections >> |
|
12/23/08 |
| For inauguration prayers, Obama splits ticket
A good thing or a bad thing?
There have been plenty of reports and reactions to
President-elect Barack Obama’s choice of pastors to pray at his
inauguration: Southern Baptist Rev. Rick Warren, of Saddleback
Community Church in Orange County, Calif., which draws more than
22,000 worshippers weekly, and who is one of the leading voices of
evangelical Christianity these days; and the Rev. Joseph Lowery, 87,
who is considered the dean of the civil rights movement.
Rachell Zoll, AP religion writer, quotes David
Domke, author of The God Strategy: How Religion Became a
Political Weapon in America: "Here's a guy who wants to run a
progressive administration getting a substantial lift in his wings
from the nation's most popular evangelical," Domke said. "But he
balances that with Joseph Lowery, who speaks to the more liberal,
social justice and African-American heritage."
Read her article >>
Many of Obama’s supporters have been offended by
his choice of one of the leading voices in support of “Prop 8" in
California, which is aimed to ban all marriages except the
“one-man-one-woman” type.
For example, Kathryn Kolbert, president of
People for the American Way, writes:
President-elect Obama's soaring campaign speeches included ... calls
for Americans to unite around what brings us together rather than
what tear us apart, and we deeply appreciate that he wants to heal
the divide in our often deeply polarized country. But Rick Warren is
a powerful leader who marginalizes and dehumanizes those who
disagree with him – he does nothing to help unite Americans!
In
an interview just last week, Warren compared reproductive choice to
the Holocaust and compared same-sex marriage to incest and
pedophilia, and he called Christians who work to advance social
justice gospel "Marxism in Christian clothing." ... Is this the sort
of inclusion millions of Americans voted for on November 4?
For the complete letter from Kolbert >>
Presbyterian minister the Rev. John Shuck, after offering a
number of comments on the whole thing, decided to put forth his own
solution: his own prayer for the Inauguration – in case anybody asks
him.
If Obama had done the right thing and invited
me to give the invocation, here is what I would have said:
I offer no prayer to any deity. Those who wish
to pray may do so on their own. Instead, I invite us to
celebrate and to contemplate the virtues of reason, justice,
equality, and compassion that are available to all human beings.
The challenges we face are immense.
May we put away selfishness, greed, and
short-sightedness.
May we work together against all forms of
tyranny.
May we seek as our highest and our common goal
the well-being of future generations.
May we work as tirelessly for the rights of
others as for our own.
May we find a way to live within our means,
with one another, with our non-human relatives, and with Earth.
And may we discover the courage, intelligence,
imagination, and compassion available within us and among us to
face the great work that lies ahead.
For John
Shuck’s blog >>
For the "inaugural prayer" entry above>>
So
now it’s your turn!
What are your thoughts on Obama’s choices?
And if he were to turn to you
instead of Warren or Lowery or Shuck,
what would be your prayer?
Please
send a note,
to be shared here! |
|
In this Christmas season,
our thoughts and prayers turn to Bethlehem and the land of Jesus'
birth |
|
The 2008 Christmas message from the Washington
Office includes:
|
|
From the
Israel/Palestine Mission Network The
Israel/Palestine Mission Network invites us to join in their letter
to President-elect Obama before his inauguration – supporting
“Israel's right to exist and right to live in safety and security,
[as well as] peace and justice in Palestine.”
Here is their
email note seeking signers for the letter >>
Click here for the
full text of their letter to Obama >> |
| |
| From the PC(USA) Campaign for
Fair Food: Two sentenced for slavery; PC(USA)
calls on Florida’s Gov. Crist to act
For the latest
report from Noelle Damico on developments in Florida with the
Coalition of Immokalee Workers >> |
| A mission co-worker responds to Weston’s call for
a “new Presbyterian
Establishment” We received this note on
Sunday, Dec. 21:
Dear friends,
I am a retired PCUSA mission co worker, and I have
worked in Venezuela, Colombia and Spain in three theological
education centers. I am never invited to respond to anything, since
I have lived outside of the States for a good time and cannot
understand the concept of high steeple churches. Most Presbyterian
and Reformed Christians live in small communities with no buildings.
Most Reformed Christians are poor in the real world.
I do not understand the discourse Weston uses, nor
do I wish to. I am alarmed about the way we are eliminating the
prophetic and cutting edge of our great denomination.
I just pray that we will indeed become a
multinational and yea, verily, even a Spanish speaking denomination.
It will broaden our wings, open our eyes, and help us to meet the
real challenges of our time. English [language] and tall steeples
restrain our visionary sense of life.
Greetings to all, from Venezuela.
Rev. Donna Laubach Moros, D.Min. retired,
Presbytery of Middle Tennessee
Teacher
Seminario Teologico de la Gran Colombia
Seminario Evangelico Unido de Teologia, España
What are your thoughts about this perspective
(not “outside the box,” maybe, but outside the States)?
Please share your thoughts,
and send us
a note! |
| Reflections on Hope, MILK and God's Love breaking
in this Advent & Christmas... Michael J. Adee,
Executive Director & Field Organizer of More Light Presbyterians,
offers his Christmas reflections. He begins:
Of Advent and Christmas, Madeline L'Engle in
her book, The Winter of the Heart, said: "This is the
irrational season when love blooms bright and wild. Had Mary
been filled with reason, there'd have been no room for the
Child."
More >>
|
|
12/19/08 |
|
Witherspoon joins others in concern over “reorganization” in racial
ethnic and women’s ministries and advocacy groups
Responding to the recent
“reorganization” affecting racial ethnic and women’s groups and
programs, the Witherspoon Society has sent a short letter to the leaders
of the Advocacy Committee for Women’s Concerns, the National Network of
Presbyterian College Women, and Racial Ethnic Young Women Together, with
copies to staff and members of the General Assembly Council, expressing
“shock and dismay” at the loss of excellent staff leadership and the
weakening of “the great history of our denomination’s commitment to
advocacy on behalf of gender and racial justice in church and society.”
The Witherspoon Moderator, the Rev. Jake Young, then
pledges to the three groups: “We stand ready to support you—and to ask
our members to support you—in any way that will be helpful.”
For the
full text of the letter >>
If you
have comments to share on this matter
or suggestions of possible courses
of action,
please send a note,
to be shared here.
|
| Beau Weston, writer on “a new
Presbyterian Establishment,” responds to criticisms from Witherspoon
and others On October 31,
we
posted a short essay raising some critical questions about Prof.
Weston’s proposal that the PC(USA) needs to return to the good old
days of its supposed power and glory, when a “Presbyterian
Establishment” (his term) of older white males, mostly clergy, and
many tall-steeple pastors, appeared to manage the denomination so
well.
Since then, a large group of professors at
Presbyterian seminaries, and others, have issued
a
similar and much sharper critique.
And most recently, the Rev. Dr. Vic Pentz, pastor
of Peachtree Presbyterian Church in Atlanta, sent us
a note
expressing his lack of interest – even as pastor of the largest
congregation in the denomination – in playing the Establishment
role.
Dr. Weston has now responded, arguing that Pentz
is not saying, as we summarized his note, that he has “more
important things to do” – although we thought that being “out in the
world with our congregations joining God in the work of the Kingdom"
might qualify for most of us as being more important than playing
Establishment Leader.
But why don’t you
read Weston’s blog (on his delightfully titled “Gruntledcenter”
blogspot) for yourself.
And if you have thoughts of your
own to share –
for or against any of these writers! –
please
send a note,
to be shared here.
Click here for a
whole page of comments and analyses >> |
| Other leaders
support Richard Cizik in his resignation from National Association
of Evangelicals
We recently reported
on the resignation of Richard Cizik, long-time leader in the growing
and broadening public witness of the evangelical community, because
he is apparently not willing to back down on his increasingly open
attitude toward committed same-sex relationships.
Now over 50 evangelical leaders, many of them
influential in the NAE, have joined in supporting his leadership in
moving the NAE toward “a broad, wholegospel agenda [which] is
reflected in the NAE's official policy statement, For the Health of
the Nation: An Evangelical Call to Civic Responsibility, which he
helped write and implement. Its principles of protecting religious
liberty, nurturing families, the sanctity of life, justice and
compassion for the least of these, human rights, seeking peace, and
protecting God's creation must remain an enduring contribution to
the Evangelical public witness in America.”
The full text of the letter >>
Also ...
Progressive evangelical Sojourners leader Jim
Wallis praises Cizik as a “pioneer for New Evangelicals”
See Wallis’
blog >> |
| "Thousands Made Slaves" in
Darfur BBC News reports that a recent study
shows strong evidence of children and adults being used as slaves in
Sudan's Darfur region. Kidnapped men have been forced to work on
farmland controlled by Janjaweed militias, the Darfur Consortium
says. Eyewitnesses also say the Sudanese army has been involved in
abducting women and children to be sex slaves and domestic staff for
troops in Khartoum.
More
>>
And for our
earlier reports on Darfur and Sudan >> |
|
12/17/08 |
Rabbi Arthur Waskow on
Newsweek, Same-Sex Marriage, & TorahRabbi
Waskow, director of the Shalom
Center in Philadelphia,
was one of the religious leaders interviewed
for the Newsweek article on same-sex marriage. He responds to the
article by saying that his comments were seriously oversimplified,
and argues that the whole issue could be understood more clearly if
we recognize that Torah, Hebrew Scripture, is rooted in human
experience and culture, and our understanding of Torah must evolve
as culture evolves.
So he concludes:
Try thinking about the
Torah as not only a living wisdom for the future but an echo of real
life from the past – try to understand it as a breathing
crystallization of the lives of the people. THAT is why at the
Burning Bush moment the future tense is crucial, just as earlier –
when the issue was fruitfulness and procreation for the troubled
clan of Abraham, down to Joseph, it was crucial for God to be El
Shaddai – the God of Breasts, the Nurturing God.
The future tense –
Becoming – is what we need today. Instead of rigidly defending
marriage as it used to be, we can honor the God Who Becomes by
expanding the circles in which marriage – a new kind of marriage –
becomes possible.
The full essay
by Rabbi Waskow >>
Thanks to Jim Green for suggesting that we add this to the
discussion of the Newsweek article. |
| The
General Assembly Finally Got it Right:
Top Ten Questions about the
Fidelity/Chastity Standard from a Single Presbyterian
C. K. Walter writes to support the proposed
amendment of the “fidelity and chastity” requirement in provision
6-6.0106b of the Book of Order. His concern is focused not on
the question of homosexuality, but on the church’s expression –
whether intentional or not – of suspicion and condemnation of most
adult singles in the church and the wider society.
The full essay
>> |
|
12/15/08 |
| Homelessness, hunger on rise in US cities
Agence France-Presse reports:
Homelessness and hunger increased in an
overwhelming majority of 25 US cities in the past year, driven
by the foreclosure crisis and rising unemployment, a survey
showed Friday.
Out of 25 cities across the United States
surveyed by the US Conference of Mayors, 83 percent said
homelessness in general had increased over the past year while
16 cities, or nearly two-thirds of those polled, cited a rise in
the number of families who had been forced out of their homes.
In Louisville, Kentucky, the number of
homeless families increased 58 percent in 2008 to 931 families
from 591 people in 2007, with the rise blamed on soaring food,
health care, transportation and energy prices.
The
rest of the story >>
Can you add to this?
Does this report mesh
with your own community these days? What’s your sense of what’s
being done about the rising incidence of homeless and hunger where
you are? Are you aware of things that churches or others are doing,
that might be helpful models for the rest of us?
Please send
a note, to be shared here! |
|
Darfur update Bill Andress, of the Sudan
Advocacy Forum, provides the latest update on the situation in Sudan
and Darfur -- with continuing genocide, but some bits of hope.
The main topics in this update:
|
| A little Christmas story – when
God didn’t do quite enough THE
MISSING FIVE POUND NOTE
Chippenham George worked for the Post Office and
his job was to process all the mail that had illegible addresses.
One day just before Christmas, a letter landed on his desk simply
addressed in shaky handwriting: 'To God'. With no other clue on the
envelope, George opened the letter and read:
Dear God,
I am an 93 year old widow living on the State
pension. Yesterday someone stole my purse. It had £100 in it,
which was all the money I had in the world and no pension due
until after Christmas. Next week is Christmas and I had invited
two of my friends over for Christmas lunch. Without that money,
I have nothing to buy food with. I have no family to turn to,
and you are my only hope. God; can you please help me?
Chippenham George was really touched, and being
kind hearted, he put a copy of the letter up on the staff notice
board at the main Fareham sorting office where he worked. The letter
touched the other postmen and they all dug into their pockets and
had a whip round. Between them they raised £95. [$190 USD] Using an
officially franked Post Office envelope, they sent the cash on to
the old lady, and for the rest of the day, all the workers felt a
warm glow thinking of the nice thing they had done.
Christmas came and went. A few days later, another
letter simply addressed to 'God' landed in the Sorting Office. Many
of the postmen gathered around while George opened the letter. It
read,
Dear God,
How can I ever thank you enough for what you
did for me? Because of your generosity, I was able to provide a
lovely luncheon for my friends. We had a very nice day, and I
told my friends of your wonderful gift – in fact we haven't
gotten over it and even Father John, our parish priest, is
beside himself with joy. By the way, there was £5 [$10 USD]
missing. I think it must have been those thieving fellows at the
Post Office.
George could not help musing on Oscar Wilde's
quote: 'A good deed never goes unpunished'
Thanks to John Jackson and his
“Everything Is Connected” email newsletter
For other Christmas stories poems, and more >> |
|
Lightheartedness as a good Christian virtue
The Rev. John Shuck, in
his sermon on December 14th, the Third Sunday of Advent,
focused on lightheartedness – a virtue in somewhat short supply
these days, perhaps, but one we might take more seriously. If
“seriously” is the way to take it?
You might enjoy the
sermon too – complete with poetry about feathers.
See it on his blog >> |
| More on Newsweek's article on marriage
equality We recently posted a short note about
a recent issue of Newsweek, which offers some very helpful
reflections on marriage equality, and reasons why the so-called
Biblical arguments against same-sex marriage are less than
compelling.
The Rev.
Len Bjorkman
offers further thoughts, questioning some of the points made by
one of the Newsweek writers. |
|
12/13/08 |
| One GAC member questions the “redesign” of
racial ethnic and women’s offices
The Rev. Melissa DeRosia, a member of the General
Assembly Council, and pastor of First Presbyterian Church in Caro,
Michigan, has written to other members of the Council, with copies to
staff members involved, expressing deep concern about the changes being
made, and the dismissal of staff. She notes especially the concern of
young women whose programs are most seriously affected, the lack of
consultation in the process, and the lack of any rationale for the
changes being made.
The
full text of her letter >>
Background on this
"redesign" >>
If you have comments on this matter,
please send a note,
to be shared here. |
| Two victories for worker justice
Workers win at Republic Windows in Chicago
Interfaith Worker Justice offered congratulations to
Local 1110 for a historic victory that ended a six-day occupation of
the Republic Windows and Doors plant in Chicago. On Wednesday, Dec.
10, the company's workers voted to accept a $1.75 million
settlement.
More >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Smithfield Packing workers choose union
representation
Workers at Smithfield Packing, the world’s largest
meatpacking plant, vote yes to union representation
Jobs with Justice announces that
this week workers at Smithfield Packing in Tar Heel, North Carolina,
chose union representation with the United Food and Commercial
Workers International Union (UFCW). Workers voted 2041 to 1879 for a
voice on the job.
More >> |
| "We
are on our own, and we are not alone." If
you believe that faith never changes, and that “Church” should be a
reasonably stable set of beliefs and behaviors that we can depend on
in a changing world – then DON’T READ THIS SERMON.
But if you believe that faith is a radical
attitude of trust which enables us to be open to the new and the
strange, even to the “Other;” if you think living as “Church” means
being on a journey, a pilgrimage with no settled end, but always
moving forward, higher, deeper, into light and often through
darkness – and that we do this best when we have the right kind of
company on the way – then
read this
reflection/sermon.
And let’s talk about it!
Just
send a note. |
| Another response to “a new Presbyterian
Establishment”
The Rev. Vic Pentz, pastor of
Peachtree Presbyterian
Church in Atlanta, Georgia, has sent this comment on Dr. Beau
Weston’s paper urging the creation of “a new Presbyterian
Establishment.” We might note that Peachtree is listed as having
over 8,500 members, which we assume qualifies as the kind of
“tall-steeple” congregation which Weston discusses as a source of
the right kind of leadership for the PC(USA). Pentz is saying (in
your WebWeaver’s crude summary) he has more important things to do.
Dr. Pentz' note
>>
More on the Weston
paper >> |
|
Moderator’s Webcast conversation on “rebuilding the
Presbyterian Establishment” draws over 200 viewers.
Here’s the
Presbyterian News Service report >> |
| Newsweek attacked from the Right for its
cover story on marriage equality More Light Presbyterians urges
that we let them hear other voices:
Please do take a moment to send a note to
Newsweek thanking them for the marriage equality cover story.
Sadly, Newsweek is being bombarded right
now by anti-gay extremist religious voices. After the narrow
anti-gay, unjust victory in California with Prop-8, anti-gay people
seem to be flexing their muscles once again and behaving like
school-yard bullies.
If we, the progressive faith voices do not speak
up and are not heard, the extreme anti-gay religious voices will
dominate the conversation and continue to be bullies.
No more bullies, just more light and more love!
To speak out and send an email go to
http://www.hrcactioncenter.org/campaign/newsweek
Thanks,
Michael
Michael J. Adee,
Executive Director & Field Organizer,
More Light Presbyterians |
| Richard Cizik resigns from the National
Association of Evangelicals Longtime
lobbyist and media spokesman recently said 'I'm shifting' on gay
unions.
Richard Cizik resigned Wednesday night as vice
president for governmental affairs of the National Association of
Evangelicals (NAE) during a week of growing uproar over his comments
that he is shifting his views on same-sex unions.
The report from Christianity Today >> |
|
12/10/08 |
| PCUSA professors and theological educators
respond to “Rebuilding the Presbyterian Establishment”
Over thirty faculty members and theological educators
at most of the Presbyterian Church seminaries, and at other
seminaries and colleges, have joined to produce a brief statement
which is sharply critical of the occasional paper entitled
“Rebuilding the Presbyterian Establishment,” by William J. (Beau)
Weston, which was published earlier this year by the Office of
Theology and Worship of the PCUSA General Assembly. (Click
here for a comment from the Witherspoon Society on Weston’s
paper.)
The signers of the document, who include former
Stated Clerk Clifton Kirkpatrick, now teaching at Louisville
Presbyterian Theological Seminary, and Dr. Eugene TeSelle, professor
emeritus at Vanderbilt Divinity School (and Witherspoon Society’s
Issues Analyst), state in their opening paragraph: “While we
celebrate the intent and desire of the author to offer a
constructive reflection on the future of the Presbyterian Church, we
are deeply troubled by the perceived authoritative status vested in
this document by many of its readers and the perceived endorsement
of this document by Theology and Worship. As professors and
theological educators associated with the PCUSA we feel called to
highlight several problematic aspects of the document that draw into
question its legitimacy as a source of theological discernment on
the future of the Presbyterian Church.”
They summarize each of their points thus:
1) The author does not provide qualitative or
quantitative data to support his assertion that increasingly
inclusive leadership in the structures of the PCUSA has led to its
decline.
2) The argument to “rebuild the Presbyterian
Establishment” is rooted in a model of ecclesiological power and
authority rooted in a hierarchical rule that has clearly been
rejected by the PCUSA as oppressive and unbiblical.
3) The proposal for “rebuilding the Presbyterian
establishment” fails to respond to the needs of the church in the 21st
century.
4) The proposal that “tall-steeple” pastors, who
Weston claims are the “natural leaders of the church,” should
provide the primary leadership of the denomination will reestablish
a denomination led almost exclusively by white, male pastors.
5) The claim that we no longer need structures of
inclusivity fails to recognize the deeply pernicious nature of
structures of racism and sexism in our culture and our church and
contradict the Book of Order.
They conclude:
... We recognize that the challenges of the 21st
century church in the United States may very well require a
renewed conversation about the role of institutions and
structures in living out God’s reconciliation in our world.
However, we believe a more nuanced historical, theological, and
cultural analysis is required to adequately think through the
challenges before the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) in this new
century. With that in mind, we call upon leaders, friends,
colleagues, and lay-persons to engage in a meaningful and
informed dialogue on the future of the church. Indeed, there is
a critical need for ongoing reflection and discernment in
casting a faithful vision for the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)
guided by the inclusive, all encompassing, call of the Realm of
God on earth.
The full
text of the statement >>
If you have comments about this
statement,
or about Weston’s paper,
please share them!
Just
send us a note,
to be posted here. |
|
12/8/08 |
| 5 Myths About Our Ailing Health-Care System
This incisive look at the U.S. health-care system (if
“system” is the right word here) was published in the Washington
Post on Nov. 23. We’re a little slow here, but we think it offers a
very helpful survey of the problem, which will hopefully be getting
renewed attention in Washington.
The “five myths” they list are:
1. America has the best health care in the world.
2. Somebody else is paying for your health insurance.
3. We would save a lot if we could cut the administrative waste of
private insurance.
4. Health-care reform is going to cost a bundle.
5. Americans aren't ready for a major overhaul of the health-care
system.
Shannon Brownlee, a visiting scholar at the
National Institutes of Health Clinical Center, is the author of
Overtreated. Ezekiel Emanuel, an oncologist and author of
Healthcare, Guaranteed, is chairman of the center's Department
of Bioethics.
The article >>
Note: You may be asked to sign in or register to
access the article, but it’s free. |
|
Pittsburgh Presbytery refuses to change policy on gay pastors
The Pittsburgh
Post-Gazette reports that Pittsburgh Presbytery, on December 4,
rejected by a vote of 125-54 a proposal similar to one passed in
2006, which would have undone the action of the 2006 General
Assembly to allow candidates for ordination to declare in conscience
their “departure” from particular ordination standards. Because the
GA Permanent Judicial Commission struck down the 2006 action, a
majority of presbyters this time apparently thought the same fate
would await a similar action, and voted against it.
The
full report >> |
Make sure you check the latest issue of
Newsweek. The cover story is about gay marriage and the
Bible,
Gay Marriage: Our Mutual Joy:
Opponents of gay marriage often cite
Scripture. But what the Bible teaches about love argues
for the other side.
Let's try for a minute to take the
religious conservatives at their word and define
marriage as the Bible does. Shall we look to Abraham,
the great patriarch, who slept with his servant when he
discovered his beloved wife Sarah was infertile? Or to
Jacob, who fathered children with four different women
(two sisters and their servants)? Abraham, Jacob, David,
Solomon and the kings of Judah and Israel—all these
fathers and heroes were polygamists. The New Testament
model of marriage is hardly better. Jesus himself was
single and preached an indifference to earthly
attachments—especially family. The apostle Paul (also
single) regarded marriage as an act of last resort for
those unable to contain their animal lust. "It is better
to marry than to burn with passion," says the apostle,
in one of the most lukewarm endorsements of a treasured
institution ever uttered. Would any contemporary
heterosexual married couple—who likely woke up on their
wedding day harboring some optimistic and newfangled
ideas about gender equality and romantic love—turn to
the Bible as a how-to script?
Of course
not, yet the religious opponents of gay marriage would
have it be so.
(Read More)
You will want
to check other articles in this week's issue and in past
issues:
- A Gay
Marriage Surge:
Public Support Grows According to the New
Newsweek Poll
- And Anna
Quindlen's editorial:
The Same People
- Miller v.
Jenkins:
One Gay Couple's Custody Battle
-
Photo Gallery: A Changing Tide
-
Why I Got Married Before California's
Prop 8 Vote
-
Long Invisible: Gay Seniors Seek Respect,
Services
-
How My Same-Sex Wedding Made Me an
Activist
Also see these videos as well:
Is Gay the
New Black? and
From
Stonewall to Prop 8.
Thank you, Newsweek!!
And thank you, John!
|
|
Presbyterian Peacemaking Program Update
December 8, 2008
The Presbyterian Peacemaking Program staff wishes
you a blessed Advent and a joyous celebration of Christmas.
NEW PEACE NOTES
The Winter 2009 issue of Peace Notes is available
at
http://www.pcusa.org/peacemaking/pubs/pubs.htm#1 .
This double issue is optimized for the Web;
pictures will be fuzzy compared to the print version. Adobe Acrobat
is required.
SPECIAL NOTE
On December 11, CNN will broadcast a documentary
“Planet in Peril” that will include information on work done
at La Oroyo, Peru by Presbyterians and Peruvian partners.
More >>
For almost all the items in the Peacemaking
Updates,
click here >> |
|
12/5/08 |
| "Dreaming in Color"
-- an alternative to a "new Presbyterian Establishment"?
Early in 2008 a paper was published by the PC(USA)’s
Office of Theology and Worship, arguing that the key to restoring the
Presbyterian Church to its old glory lies in giving the reins of control
back to “the Presbyterian Establishment,” which means the tall-steeple
pastors and mature, successful elders (mostly male, white, straight, and
otherwise decent and orderly).
At a recent conference of moderators of
presbyteries and synods of the PC(USA), the Rev. Tony Aja preached a
sermon under the title "Dreaming in Color," which many in the group
heard as an interesting and challenging response to the
"establishment" idea.
Here's a
report on the sermon from Presbyterian News Service
And for the full text of the sermon,
click here. |
| Gradye Parsons commends CIW and Subway on
agreement Accord sends ‘unmistakable
message’ to ensure human rights, he says
Jerry Van Marter of Presbyterian News Service
reports that the Rev. Gradye Parsons, Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)
General Assembly stated clerk, has issued a statement praising the
Dec. 2 agreement between the Coalition of Immokalee Workers (CIW)
and Subway, the third-largest fast food chain in the United States.
The agreement commits Subway to take steps to
increase wages and improve working conditions for the Florida
farmworkers that harvest tomatoes for Subway’s suppliers. Subway
joins Yum! Brands – parent of Taco Bell – as well as McDonalds,
Burger King and Whole Foods grocery chain in partnering with the CIW
to improve the lot of Florida’s farmworkers and put an end to human
slavery in the fields.
“Subway’s decision sends an unmistakable message
to the rest of the retail food industry and to Florida growers,”
Parsons said. “The industry can and must ensure human rights for
farmworkers.”
He also wrote: “The significance of these
agreements is that they not only promise a significant wage increase
for farmworkers but that they also guarantee the full-participation
of farmworkers in creating and upholding a more just food system.”
The full report >>
For
earlier reports of the CIW - Subway campaign >> |
| What next for Guantánamo Bay?
Philippe Sands, professor of law at University
College London, writes in The Guardian UK:
... President Bush leaves the Obama
administration with some difficult decisions: looking back, how
to address a legacy of abuse, illegality and global disrepute?
Looking forward, what to do with present and future detainees?
Obama needs to say five things on day one, to America and to his
global audience.
First, he should state that he will not use
the phrase "war on terror", words that tend to legitimise the
struggle of those who seek to harm us.
Second, he should announce that the US will
... no longer use torture or cruel, inhuman and degrading
treatment, as defined by international law.
Third, he should declare the closure of
Guantanamo ...
Fourth, he must address what will happen to
the 50 or so detainees who will remain in the US ...
Fifth, he should announce that the US will
honour and underscore its historic commitment to international
efforts against impunity, so that past detainee abuses will not
be forgotten. ...
More
>> |
|
12/4/08 |
| Broader medical refusal rule may go far beyond
abortion David Savage, reporting in the Los
Angeles Times, says that the outgoing Bush administration is
planning to announce a broad new 'right of conscience' rule
permitting medical facilities, doctors, nurses, pharmacists and
other healthcare workers to refuse to participate in any procedure
they find morally objectionable, including abortion and possibly
even artificial insemination and birth control.
More >> |
| The gun lobby’s loss may free legislators
In an editorial on December 2, 2008, the New York
Times declared:
The gun lobby has long intimidated politicians
with its war chest and its trumpeted ability to deliver
single-issue voters, especially in tight races. After this
year’s election, those politicians should be far less afraid and
far more willing to vote for sensible gun-control laws.
The full editorial >> |
| "Audaciously happy here in
BLUE North Carolina!"
The Rev. Betty Hale expresses her feelings after
the recent election, and reflects on Robert Gagnon's recent warnings
that the election of Obama would open the way for a "war on
Christianity."
Her comments
>> |
|
12/2/08 |
Subway signs agreement
with Immokalee Workers!
Coalition tour continues with new
focus
This note has just come
from the Rev. Noelle Damico, PC(USA) staff person for the
Campaign for Fair Food, and liaiason to the Coalition of
Immokalee Workers
Dear Friends:
"O that You would tear open the
heavens and come down" we cried with the prophet Isaiah this
past Sunday. In a world tangled in injustice, we long for a
glimpse of God's promise of shalom. Today we received such a
glimpse.
Just a few hours ago, Subway signed
an agreement with the Coalition of Immokalee Workers to improve
farmworkers' wages and address human rights abuses in the fields
of its Florida tomato suppliers.
The agreement was reached as the
CIW and members of the religious, human rights and student
communities, gathered at Subway's purchasing cooperative, IPC,
in Miami this morning, to launch the Subway NE Tour. A signing
ceremony took place inside IPC with Subway and CIW
representatives.
The CIW's Tour will continue to
journey through NC, Washington, DC, Baltimore, Philadelphia,
Boston, Providence, New Haven and New York City in the coming
week, however the focus will shift from Subway to the rest of
the food industry. Now that Subway, the largest fast-food buyer
of Florida tomatoes, has joined Yum!, McDonald's, Burger King,
and Whole Foods Market in working with the CIW, its time for the
rest of the grocery and fast-food corporations to join their
counterparts and partner with the CIW to elevate human rights
for farmworkers in their own supply chains.
Peace,
|
|
Moderator
Bruce
Reyes-Chow plans on-line conversation with Beau Weston on
"Rebuilding the Presbyterian Establishment"
We recently posted
some critical
reflections on a booklet by Beau
Weston, entitled Rebuilding the Presbyterian
Establishment [PDF]
published by the
The Office of Theology and Worship. The paper has generated a
great deal of conversation throughout the church both praised in
some places as well as criticized in others.
Moderator Bruce
Reyes-Chow has announced that he will hold an
open, online chat with Weston on Tuesday, December 9. His
announcement continues:
Using the webcasting technology found at
ustream.tv
you will be able to join the conversation via chatroom. I will
act as host, there will be a moderator to help track questions
and we will take some time to talk with Beau, gets some
responses and interact with you all.
It is my hope to use this medium more fully in the future to
engage with folks throughout the church both "known" and
"unknown" as we try to navigate this time in our life as
Presbyterians.
Here are the details:
Moderator Musings, Episode 2: A conversation with
Beau Weston
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
3:00-4:00pm EST
Webcast Location
Facebook Event Page
Facebook "Rebuilding the Presbyterian Establishment" Group
Twitter to
#RPE
If you plan on joining in on the conversation on the 9th, you
should
go on over to register now so you can follow the show and be
sure to be part of the conversation.
See you Tuesday!
Bruce Reyes-Chow
|
|
12/1/08 |
| Season of Hunger: A Crisis of
Food Inflation & Shrinking Safety Nets in the U.S.
This will be a grim Thanksgiving for millions in the
U.S.
Hunger and food insecurity is on the increase in
the U.S. as families face ultimatums: to pay for food or rent, food
or medicine. The situation has been made worse with the U.S. facing
the worst food inflation in 17 years. Families are running out of
food by the end of the month, parents are skipping meals so children
can have enough to eat, and families are doing without minimally
adequate, balanced and healthy diets.
Children are among the most vulnerable U.S.
populations. According to a recent report from the USDA, hunger
among children worsened in 2007, increasing by more than 50 percent.
691,000 children suffered from hunger sometime in 2007, up
significantly from 430,000 in 2006.
A new Briefing Paper from the Oakland Institute,
Season of Hunger : A Crisis of Food Inflation & Shrinking Safety
Nets in the U.S., examines the causes of growing hunger and food
insecurity in the U.S. and suggests long term and structural changes
required to reform the precarious food system, emergency food
assistance programs, wages, and employment in the United States.
Read the
Briefing Paper >> |
| Gains among women in the clergy
are under attack in both Catholic and Protestant churches.
The L. A. Times, in a brief editorial, takes
note of the reality that while women may be playing expanding roles
in their churches, including ordained ministry (well, for many
Protestant churches, at least), there is growing resistance to this
development, in Protestant as well and Catholic churches.
The closing paragraph sums it up:
In the Roman Catholic Church, tradition is
cited as the grounds for not ordaining women. In Protestant
churches, resistance to female pastors is likelier to be
grounded in biblical passages such as 1 Timothy 2:12: "And I do
not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man, but
to be in silence." In either case, the arguments that keep women
from full participation are attributed to a higher authority. So
why do they sound so much like the complaints about assertive
women that long have issued from the mouths of men?
The full editorial >> |
| A Call for Remembrance, Prayer
& Ministry on World AIDS Day, December 1.
Started on December 1, 1988, World AIDS Day is about increasing
awareness, fighting prejudice, raising money and improving
education. World AIDS Day is important in reminding people that HIV
has not gone away, and that there are many things still to be done.
AIDS was first identified in the USA in 1981. The
epidemic has now spread to every part of the USA and to all sectors
of society. It is thought that more than one million people are
living with HIV in the USA and that more than half a million have
died after developing AIDS in the USA.
More – including suggestions for what you and your church,
youth group, campus ministry or seminary community can do >> |
|
Christmas can [still]
change the world.
The story of Christ's birth is a story of promise,
hope, and a revolutionary love.
So, what happened?
What was once a time to celebrate the birth of a savior has somehow
turned into a season of stress, traffic jams, and shopping lists.
And when it's all
over, many of us are left with presents to return, looming debt that
will take months to pay off, and this empty feeling of missed
purpose. Is this what we really want out of Christmas?
What if Christmas
became a world-changing event again?
Welcome to Advent
Conspiracy.
Worship Fully,
Spend Less,
Give More,
Love All
Here’s a simple,
provocative affirmation of the meaning of Advent today.
For more on the group
that’s behind this,
go to their FAQ page.
Thanks to John
Shuck for suggesting this.
More
reflections for Advent >> |
 |
| Photo courtesy of Wabash
College |
Presbyterian
theologian and teacher Bill Placher dies at age 60
Wabash College has
announced the death of “one of its most influential teachers and
scholars. William C. Placher ’70, the LaFollette Distinguished
Professor in the Humanities, passed away over the weekend at the age
of 60.”
Placher is best known in Presbyterian circles, perhaps, as one of
the members of the committee that produced the Brief Statement of
Faith of the reunited PC(USA).
More >> |
|
For an index to all our reports
and analyses
on the 219th General Assembly
For links to
all our archive pages, listed by months,
click here. |
| |
|
Visit
our lively
new website! |
|
GA actions
ratified (or not) by the presbyteries
A number of the most important actions of the 219th
General Assembly have now been acted upon by the presbyteries,
confirming most of them as amendments to the PC(USA) Book of Order.
We provided resources to help inform the
reflection and debate, along with updates on the voting.
Our three areas of primary interest have been:
 |
Amendment 10-A,
which removes the current ban on
lesbian/gay/bisexual/transgender persons being considered as
possible candidates for ordination as elder or ministers.
Approved! |
 |
Amendment 10-2,
which would add the Belhar Confession to our Book of
Confessions. Disapproved, because as an amendment
to the Book of Confessions it needed a 2/3 vote, and did not
receive that. |
 |
Amendment
10-1, which adopts the new Form of Government
that was approved by the Assembly. Approved. |
|
| |
|
If you like what
you find here,
we hope you'll help us keep Voices for Justice going ... and
growing!
Please consider making a special
contribution -- large or small -- to help us continue and improve
this service.
Click here to send a
gift online, using your credit card, through PayPal.
Or send your check, made
out to "Presbyterian Voices for Justice" and marked "web site," to
our PVJ Treasurer:
Darcy Hawk
4007 Gibsonia Road
Gibsonia, PA 15044-8312 |
| |
|
Some blogs worth visiting |
|
PVJ's
Facebook page
Mitch Trigger, PVJ's
Secretary/Communicator, has created a Facebook page where
Witherspoon members and others can gather to exchange news and
views. Mitch and a few others have posted bits of news, both
personal and organizational. But there’s room for more!
You can post your own news and views,
or initiate a conversation about a topic of interest to you. |
| |
|
Voices of Sophia blog
Heather Reichgott, who has created
this new blog for Voices of Sophia, introduces it:
After fifteen years of scholarship
and activism, Voices of Sophia presents a blog. Here, we present the
voices of feminist theologians of all stripes: scholars, clergy,
students, exiles, missionaries, workers, thinkers, artists, lovers
and devotees, from many parts of the world, all children of the God
in whose image women are made. .... This blog seeks to glorify God
through prayer, work, art, and intellectual reflection. Through
articles and ensuing discussion we hope to become an active and
thoughtful community. |
| |
|
John Harris’ Summit to
Shore blogspot
Theological and philosophical
reflections on everything between summit to shore, including
kayaking, climbing, religion, spirituality, philosophy, theology,
politics, culture, travel, The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), New
York City and the Queens neighborhood of Ridgewood by a progressive
New York City Presbyterian Pastor. John is a former member of the
Witherspoon board, and is designated pastor of North Presbyterian
Church in Flushing, NY. |
| |
|
John Shuck’s Shuck and Jive
A Presbyterian minister, currently
serving as pastor of First Presbyterian Church of Elizabethton,
Tenn., blogs about spirituality, culture, religion (both organized
and disorganized), life, evolution, literature, Jesus, and
lightening up. |
| |
|
Got more blogs to recommend?
Please
send a note, and we'll see what we can do! |
| |
|