Welcome to Witherspoon on the Web       

News and networking for progressive Presbyterians

Home page

Ordination concerns

Immigrant rights

War on Iraq

Search Archive
2006 General Assembly Global & Social concerns Election 2008 Israel & Palestine About us Just for fun

News of the PC(USA)

Torture --
It's time to resist!
Other churches, other faiths War on Iran?? Join us! Notes from your WebWeaver

What's Where

Our reports about the
2008 General Assembly

You'll find much more on the GA at JustPresbys -- the shared website of 6 progressive Presbyterian organizations.

ABOUT US

The Summer 2008 issue of
Network News
is posted here
- in Adobe PDF format.

Click here for earlier issues
Adobe PDF  Click here to download (free!) Adobe Reader software to view this and all PDF files.

News of the Society
How to join us
Witherspoon's
Global Engagement Initiative
Dancing with God -- reports from the 2005 Witherspoon conference on mission for peace and justice

SEARCH

CONNECTIONS

Coming events calendar 

Do you want to announce an event?
Please send a note!
Food for the spirit
Book notes

Go to  Amazon.com

LINKS

NEWS of the Presbyterian Church

Got news??
Send us a note!
Women's Concerns
Social and global concerns
The Middle East conflict
The War in Iraq
Hurricane Katrina
U. S. Politics
Election 2008
Economic justice
Fair Food Campaign
Sexual justice
Amendment 08-B
for inclusive ordination
Peacemaking & international concerns
Caring for the environment
Immigrant rights
Racial concerns
Church & State
The death penalty
The media
OTHER CHURCHES, OTHER FAITHS
Do you want regular e-mail updates when stories are added to our web site?
Just send a note!
The WebWeaver's Space
ARCHIVES
JUST FOR FUN
Want books?
Search Now:

 

The Rev. Donald Smith, a member of the staff of the Synod of Southern California and Hawaii, sent this open letter to John Detterick, Executive Director of the General Assembly Council.  In it he supports not simply Ficca's right to say what he said, but also the content of his address on interfaith dialogue.

Check out a more recent comment following discussion by GAC in February, 2001.

December 8, 2000



From

Rev. Donald L. Smith
Synod of Southern California and Hawaii
1501 Wilshire Blvd.
Los Angeles, CA 90017

To

John Detterick
Executive Director, General Assembly Council
100 Witherspoon Street
Louisville, KY 40202-1396

Subject: Ficca Peacemaking Address



Dear John:

I write you as a friend and colleague in the denomination we both care deeply about. Count me as one of many who attended the 2000 Peacemaking Conference at Chapman University and found tremendous value in the theme address by the Rev. Dirk Ficca. As leader of one of the discussion groups following that presentation, I can testify that he made a substantial positive impact on those in my group. One woman pastor from Iowa confessed to me privately at the end of the session that followed Ficca's address, her eyes brimming with tears, that perhaps she could remain a Presbyterian after all.

I have been increasingly dismayed by the escalation of the controversy this address has spawned in our denomination as I have seen us fall into a pattern that appears all too sad and familiar. I have the text of the address as well as the audio tape and have returned repeatedly to give it closer scrutiny as this debate has progressed. It appears to me now that I need to speak up. Regrettably, I believe some in our church seem to have found a useful "weapon" in this address to further a rather narrow and exclusionary agenda. Unfortunate remarks you reportedly made on October 31, 2000 before the Presbyterian Coalition characterizing this address as "out of bounds" were a great disappointment to me. I honestly do not believe they have served us well.

Prior to the recent creation of the General Assembly Committee on Ecumenical Relations, I represented the Synod of Southern California and Hawaii on the Synod Section of the Advisory Committee on Ecumenical and Interfaith Relations for five years. You know me best as the staff to the Stewardship and Mission Rally in this synod. I am also currently President of the Southern California Ecumenical Council, Chair of the Theology and Ecumenical Relations Committee in the Presbytery of the Pacific and a board member for the Interfaith Coalition for Immigrant Rights here in California. In addition, I serve as a Parish Associate for United University Church on the campus of the University of Southern California - a union congregation of United Methodist and PCUSA partners. My history of ecumenical and interfaith work spans the last twenty years, particularly as I have worked in refugee resettlement and immigration ministries in close association with Church World Service.

With the passage of time, I am more and more convinced that Dirk Ficca delivered an important and difficult message that our church needs to hear for the challenging times in which we live. I don't refer to the "What's the big deal about Jesus?" remark lifted out of context in some articles written by persons who never actually heard him speak. More central to the message was Ficca's controversial observation that persons of other faiths often experience sincere Christian evangelism to be a kind of religious "ethnic cleansing." This is actually a far more challenging assertion which, I submit, we need to examine thoughtfully, with humility and prayer.

This is especially true in a denomination that holds "evangelism" as a primary goal and measures the value of programs by how well they fulfill that goal. As you and Cliff Kirkpatrick travel around the country, lifting up ways in which our times resemble those in which the early church found itself, do we forget the Christian history that followed? Indeed, there were numerous times when devout Christians did practice religious "ethnic cleansing." Even John Calvin, in the "justice" he meted out to Servetus in Geneva, left himself open to charges of that kind of intolerance. The people of other faiths we increasingly encounter today may be much more aware of that history than that of the first century Church. Some may well have strong reasons to distrust our Gospel.

In light of Ficca's observation, it is urgent that we give attention to issues of the meaning of "pluralism" and "dialogue." After hosting a conference in 1999 which explored the person of Jesus under the theme "Who Do You Say That I Am?," the Peacemaking Conference in 2000 did an exemplary job of exploring these issues in depth. One of the most eloquent contributions in this regard came from Dirk Ficca as he spoke out of his deep and many-faceted experiences of interaction with other faiths in his capacity as Executive Director of the Parliament of World Religions.

As he discussed the differing lenses through which we view "truth," (i.e., relativist exclusivist, inclusivist, reductionist, culturalist, humanist, synchronist, pluralist and particularist) many in the audience developed new understanding for approaches they had not previously considered. How many had even previously imagined how to open dialogue about faith issues with persons of other faiths? Starting from a Christian "particularist" perspective, Ficca helped the audience to envision how that might take shape with integrity and respect on both sides. The alternatives of the "instrumental" vs. the "revelatory" streams for interpretation of Scripture, of Jesus Christ, and of salvation were especially illustrative of ways in which the door is opened or closed to genuine and meaningful dialogue with persons of other faiths.

Not too many years ago we used to see bumper stickers that read "God said it. I believe it. That settles it!" Nothing could be further from the spirit of genuine "dialogue" than that. Many in the PCUSA, however, are faulting Dirk Ficca and the planners of the Peacemaking Conference today because what Dirk said does not embrace that kind of approach to truth. By contrast, The Office of Ecumenical and Interfaith Relations of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) in its publication Handbook for Ecumenical and Interfaith Relations states, "Dialogue respects the other. It therefore has no prior motives or imposed goals brought by one side to require of the other. It is based upon mutuality, even mutuality in witness." (p. 25 "Guidelines for Interfaith Dialogue and Relationships")

What I think would better serve our denomination than what we are seeing today is a return to a more balanced, responsible and tolerant discussion of these issues and the persons who have in good faith tried to advance our understanding of them. They should be applauded for rising to a difficult challenge in a thoughtful, creative and entirely responsible way -- not maligned and abused. I trust that when General Assembly Council meets in February, we will see more of that model of leadership from you.

Respectfully,


Rev. Donald L. Smith
Director for Regional Ministries

 
 

If you like what you find here,
we hope you'll help us keep this website going ... and growing!

Please consider making a special contribution -- large or small -- to help us continue and improve this service.

Click here to send a gift online, using your credit card, through PayPal.

Or send your check, made out to "Witherspoon Society" and marked "web site," to our Witherspoon  Bookkeeper:

Susan Robertson  
9650 Clover Circle
Eden Prairie, MN  55347

 

An index of our reports from

 

 

 

BECOMING NEIGHBORS:
An Invitation
to Global Discipleship

A Witherspoon conference
on global mission and justice

September 16 - 19, 2007
Louisville, Kentucky

 

Check out our report from the Conference
on
Terror, Torture,
and Security

 

To top

© 2007 by The Witherspoon Society.  All material on this site is the responsibility of the WebWeaver unless other sources are acknowledged.  Unless otherwise noted, material on this site may be copied for personal use and sharing in small groups.  For permission to reproduce material for wider publication, please contact the WebWeaver, Doug King.  Any material reached by links on this site is outside the control and responsibility of the WebWeaver and The Witherspoon Society.  Questions or comments?  Please send a note!